🔗 Share this article

“They endeavored to murder us. They did not succeed. Let’s dine,” commented Andrew Walters.

That traditional Hebrew joke feels notably relevant in Greater Manchester in the face of present-day dangers.

For the councillor, the good-humoured statement encapsulates the unyielding spirit that characterises his traditional Jewish community.

This dynamic district was singled out by an extremist terror cell, whose scheme to “slay as many Jews as possible” in a violent gun incident was foiled. Two individuals were convicted this week on terrorism charges.

Community Solidarity and Everyday Struggles

In the words of Walters, the disrupted scheme has not diminished the neighbourhood’s commitment to live harmoniously with its wider community. “My business partner is a religious Muslim and we get on great,” said the father of nine. “There’s good and bad in any group. The vast majority just want to live in harmony.”

The individuals saw the Hebrew community solely through the distorted view of antisemitism.

They showed no curiosity in the varied ways of life, financial situations, levels of observance and political views within the city’s Jewish communities, nor in the serious social concerns like financial hardship that impact many UK communities.

A local leader runs a family support centre that aids hundreds of families, including large strictly observant families and some Muslim women. The service delivers parenting support, clinics, guidance, learning programs, and crucial financial and material support.

“People outside believe the primary issue is safety – that is incorrect,” Ciffer Klein said. “Of course we’re sad and we pray, but the women I work with are finding it hard to cope with daily routines, pressure and large families. We are here to help.”

“Inflation – kosher food is very costly – utility costs, people who can’t afford milk and nappies, accommodation, benefits issues – these are what I’m focused on.”

Heightened Security and Unbroken Spirit

Despite these pressures, two common themes have strengthened under pressure. One is a marked shift “towards community solidarity and participation,” per a major community research organisation. The other is a atmosphere of vigilance on a level rare in most UK towns.

“We can arrive to an incident in two minutes,” said the head of a Jewish neighbourhood watch group that exchanges intelligence with authorities.

“The mood is undoubtedly strained,” they continued. “There has been a massive rise in reports to our 24-hour hotline about suspicious activities.”

Nonetheless, Walters emphasised that the observant communities, among the fastest-growing in Europe, did not live in terror. “We embrace life,” he said. “We are confident that if we die, we’re going to a a higher place. We choose not to be intimidated.”

Broader Context and Appeals for Action

Other senior community figures argue that considerably more must be done to tackle the risk of radical ideology.

While figures show that cases with clear far-right ideology outnumbered those linked to radical Islamist views last year, the most lethal plans in the past few years have been perpetrated by individuals inspired by extremist ideology.

“A significant part of our work on the safety side is trying to spot and disrupt hostile surveillance of Jewish targets that would come before an incident,” said a security head from a safety trust.

They pointed out a pattern of terror-related and anti-Jewish incidents originating from areas north of the city, leading to inquiries about the specific situation in that area.

Recent tragic attacks abroad have occurred with Hebrew holidays and commemorations, heightening a sense of worldwide unease.

Assessment on a Shifting Paradigm

Some figures believe that a post-Holocaust assumption has shifted.

“From a British perspective, there was sort of view there was a period of safety in terms of post-Holocaust awareness of what anti-Jewish hatred is,” said a spokesperson for a civic council. “It is my belief that perspective is starting to be seen as excessively optimistic.”

They continued, “It’s not that we think this time is any more risky than any of those times before, but that there’s no assumption that difficult times won’t recur.”

There is acknowledgement of the endeavours being done within Islamic communities to dispute extremist narratives, though mainstream voices can feel intimidated.

Appeals have been made for the authorities to publish a new radicalism strategy, with an focus on addressing the doctrinal challenge posed by radical views, separate from faith or individuals.

Resilience and Optimism

However, against the backdrop of security threats, a strain of positive defiance characterises even solemn occasions.

“In London to mark an anniversary, the discussion included the Manchester incident,” a leader recounted. “Spontaneously, at the end, a musician started playing Jewish tunes and people started celebrating. That is the positive spin.”

“Yet I would be lying if I said those sober conversations about the future of Jewish life in this nation haven’t been ongoing.”